Friday Sermon by: Alban Fejza, Online Congregation Director
Summary:
In this Friday sermon, Alban Fejza shows that the debate over three or five daily prayers cannot be settled from four verses alone, then maps all 19 verses that mention times of daily worship onto a timetable and shows that five prayers are the most efficient way to fulfill all of them, with rare exceptions where days are very long or short.
Video Transcript:
Praise be to God. There is no other god except God.
It has become quite trendy these days to debate hatefully about whether there are three or five Contact Prayers per day mentioned in the Quran, and both sides of this issue rely on four Quranic verses. Here they are. Verse 24:58 mentions the dawn prayer and the afternoon or evening prayer. Verse 2:238 mentions the middle prayer. Verse 11:114 mentions prayer times at the two ends of the day, and when night arrives. And verse 17:78 mentions a prayer time at the decline of the sun until the darkness of the night, and the dawn prayer.
Those who believe in three prayers say that only the first two verses mention the official prayer times, and that the last two verses just repeat or describe those same three prayers in different words. On the other hand, those who believe in five prayers say that, yes, the first two verses mention three prayers, but the last two verses mention two additional prayers which are not mentioned in the previous two verses, making a total of five prayers.
So which of these opinions is right? Well, the truth is that if we rely on these four verses alone, we, the submitters, should not reach a definite conclusion, because these verses alone do not give us sufficient information to do so. So then what is wrong here? What are they missing? In fact, they are missing a crucial verse in the Quran, which, once you read it, opens up a whole new understanding of many other verses, and only then can we reach a definite conclusion about the number of prayer times in the Quran.
Here is the verse: verse 98:5, which says that God did not make anything obligatory except to worship God sincerely in the correct religion, and to do the Contact Prayers and the Zakat. This is again reinforced in verses 9:11 and 9:5, where God tells us that if people do the Contact Prayer and the Zakat, then they fulfill all the basics of religion and should be considered brothers in religion. I know that Hajj and Ramadan are also obligatory, but at specific times of the year, and someone might decide to join the religion at another time of the year, outside of the Hajj or Ramadan seasons, and this is one of the reasons why only the Contact Prayer and Zakat are mentioned as the basics of joining the correct religion. And knowing that Zakat is an annual ritual, we can conclude that the Contact Prayers are the only obligatory daily ritual for the submitters.
Now, you might wonder what this has to do with the times of the Contact Prayers. Well, keep in mind that God is asking us to do only the Contact Prayers as daily religious rituals. But then, for example, in verse 50:39, God tells us to glorify and praise Him before sunrise and before sunset, which is a daily ritual, and it is given as an order, not as an option. The verse is expressed as a clear obligation. So if it is a daily obligation to glorify and praise God before sunrise and before sunset, wouldn’t this contradict the previous verse, where God told us that He does not order us to do anything else as a daily ritual except the Contact Prayers? Yet in the other verse He orders us to glorify and praise Him before sunrise and before sunset. This would be a logical contradiction, unless this obligatory glorification and praise of God are part of the Contact Prayers.
So this unlocks a whole new understanding. Now we understand that all the obligatory daily rituals which are mentioned in the Quran, including prostrating, bowing, glorifying God, praising God and so on, must all be part of the Contact Prayers. This means that when God tells us to do those obligatory daily rituals at a specific time of the day, He’s saying to do them at that specific time of the day as part of the Contact Prayer, which means that He is also telling us that at that specific time there must be a Contact Prayer. So now we have more verses from which we can draw conclusions about the number of Contact Prayers, because we have to expand our search to all the verses which order us to do obligatory daily rituals. In fact, now we do not only have four verses; we have a total of 19 verses which mention Contact Prayer times in the Quran.
So here are all those verses. Let’s go over them one by one, but before we do that, let’s put them in a daily timetable, to make them easier to understand. For now, let’s imagine that you live at the equator, where the day and the night are always 12 hours long, every day of the year. This will enable us to use clock times in this table, which is easier for most people to understand. According to the Quran, the night comes before the day, so the calendar day starts when the night starts, which in this case, at the equator, would be when the clock shows 19:30. So let’s present the hours here, starting from 19:30 at the edge of this table. Then we have 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, which is midnight, and then 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6:00, which is exactly when the sun rises in this example, and then 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, which is exactly midday in this example, and then 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, and then the tiny edge beyond 19 is half an hour, which makes it 19:30. So here we have represented all 24 hours of the day as they would be at the equator. We are doing this so that we can map the verses using clock times, without having to adjust for day lengths and so on.
Now let’s put all the times of the Contact Prayers which are mentioned in the Quran into this timetable. I will try to give you the literal translation from the Arabic, and every time a prayer time is mentioned with different wording, I will present it with a different color, so that you know it’s a different expression.
The first verse here is verse 25:64. In this verse, God orders us to do the Contact Prayer in the darkness of the night. Then, in the following four verses, verses 73:2, 73:20, 39:9 and 50:40, God orders us to do the Contact Prayer during the night. And then again, in verse 52:49, God orders us to do the Contact Prayer during the night and at the fading of the stars, which at the equator happens from around 4:30 until 6 a.m. By the way, some boxes here are too small to fit all the text, but you get the point: the colored box, not the text, represents the length of that time.
Let’s continue. Verse 11:114: in this verse, God orders us to do the Contact Prayers at night and at the two edges of the daylight, the beginning of the daylight and the end of the daylight. Then, in verse 20:130, God tells us to do the Contact Prayer at night, before sunrise, which is also the beginning of the daylight, and before sunset, at the end of the daylight. So now we have four Contact Prayer times mentioned in the same verse, which, by the way, means that from this verse alone we can conclude that there must be at least four prayer times, because these are all presented as different prayer times within the same verse. But let’s complete this analysis first, before we reach definite conclusions.
In verse 50:39, God tells us to do the Contact Prayers before sunrise and before sunset. In verse 30:17, God tells us to do the Contact Prayers when we reach the morning and when we reach the evening. In the following three verses, verses 33:42, 48:9 and 76:25, God orders us to do the Contact Prayers morning and evening. In verse 24:36, God tells us to do the Contact Prayers during the early day and the evening. The expression “early day” here more literally means breakfast, but in the past the time of breakfast varied from day to day and from region to region, from dawn until lunch, and in some regions today they actually understand that word as lunch. Anyway, if we look at how the root word used here in the Arabic is used in other verses of the Quran, we can see that it is talking about the period from early dawn until lunch.
Next verse: in verse 17:78, God tells us to do a Contact Prayer at dawn, and at the decline of the sun until the darkness of the night. In verse 24:58, God tells us to do a Contact Prayer at dawn and at “Isha.” To define Isha, we can look at other verses of the Quran where the root word is used, and we can see that it refers to the afternoon period plus the evening period. It includes both times, just like in English the word “brunch” includes both breakfast and lunch. We do not have an English word for Isha, so I’m translating it here as “afternoon/evening.”
By the way, traditionally they used the word Isha to refer to the night prayer, but that is because the prayers do not have official names in the Quran, and they did not have clocks in the past, so people named the prayers themselves, according to the time which had just passed, instead of the time in which they were at that moment. For example, they traditionally said “sunset prayer,” but the sun had already set; by “sunset prayer” they meant the prayer after sunset, which is the evening prayer. Or they said “noon prayer,” but what they meant was the prayer after noon happens. So don’t let the names confuse you. Even though traditionally they used the term “Isha prayer” to mean the night prayer, what they meant is that when the time of Isha has fully passed, and the time of Isha, according to the Quran, is the afternoon and evening, then we do the prayer which actually happens at night.
Next verse: in verse 30:18, God tells us to do a Contact Prayer when noon happens, and also during Isha time, which is the afternoon and/or evening. In verse 40:55, God tells us to do a Contact Prayer in the morning, and also during the afternoon and/or evening. And then, finally, in this last verse, 2:238, God tells us to do the middle prayer, and the word “middle” has many meanings here. One meaning is the middle of the day, which is noon, so let’s present it here with this green color. Another true meaning is that it’s talking about the sun being midway between the highest possible point in the sky, 90°, and the lowest possible point in the sky, 0°, and the middle of those two is 45° of elevation. So it is after the sun passes below 45° of elevation, which would be the afternoon prayer, and let’s represent it here with this brownish color.
Once we reach the conclusion that there are five Contact Prayers, another meaning is that the middle prayer is the noon prayer, because it comes after the night and dawn prayers and before the afternoon and evening prayers. As you remember, the calendar day starts with the night, and then the day follows, so this would make the night prayer the first prayer, and that would make the noon prayer the middle, or third, prayer. Another meaning of the middle prayer, which is also true, is the afternoon prayer, if we count the prayers from the moment we wake up, making the dawn prayer the first prayer and the afternoon prayer the middle prayer.
So these are all the Contact Prayer times mentioned in the Quran. They are mentioned in exactly 19 verses, with different wordings, or different expressions, and each different expression is represented by a different color in this timetable. To be proper submitters, we should fulfill all these 19 verses fully, all these colors. But what is the minimum number of daily Contact Prayers, in this equatorial day example, which would ensure that we fulfill all 19 verses?
We have already shown that it cannot be just three, because that would go against verse 20:130, which mentions four different Contact Prayer times. It would also go against verse 11:114, which mentions the night prayer and the evening, or sunset, prayer as two different prayers, which goes against their distorted belief that the night prayer and the evening, or sunset, prayer are the same prayer. And verses 17 and 18 of Sura 30 also go against their distorted belief that the afternoon prayer and the noon prayer are always the same prayer, because these verses clearly mention the afternoon and the noon prayers as two different prayers.
But anyway, how many daily Contact Prayers should there be in this example? As you can see in this timetable, we might actually be able to fulfill many verses with the same Contact Prayer. For example, if we do a Contact Prayer at dawn, we fulfill the expression to do it at dawn, but we also fulfill the expression which says to do it before sunrise. So, given that we can kill many birds with one stone, given that we can fulfill many of these 19 obligations simultaneously, what would be the most efficient way to fulfill all 19 verses of the Quran? What would be the minimum number of prayers which we have to do in this example to fulfill all the verses of the Quran?
To answer this question, let’s draw vertical arrows and try to touch all the colors here with as few arrows as possible. Let’s put an arrow here, and we fulfill all those dark blue obligations. Then let’s put another arrow here, and we fulfill all these obligations. We could also put it further to the right, but then we would have to use two arrows. We are trying to hit as many colors as possible with the same arrow, so if we put it here, further to the left, those late-morning colors are also hit, because all of them start in the early morning anyway. Now let’s put another arrow here; many colors here. If we move this arrow to the left, to try to hit these brownish colors as well, we would miss these pinkish colors to the right. This means that we have to add another arrow, so that we can hit both the brownish and the pinkish colors. So let’s add another arrow. And if we move this arrow to the left, to hit the green colors as well, we would miss the brownish ones. This means that we have to add yet another arrow to cover these green ones. Now we have finally covered all the colors, and guess how many arrows we have? We have five arrows. These five arrows are the five daily Contact Prayers.
So the five daily Contact Prayers are simply the most efficient way to fulfill all these 19 verses, all these Quranic obligations, all these colors. If you try to do it with fewer than five prayers in this equatorial day example, you would be going against at least one of these verses. And if you did it with more than five, with six for example, why would you do that? Why do six prayers when you can achieve the same results with five? As the saying goes, work smarter, not harder. So again, in these equatorial examples, the five daily Contact Prayers are simply the smartest, the most efficient, the best, the easiest way to fulfill all 19 verses of the Quran which prescribe daily rituals at specific times of the day. So the conclusion is that, according to the Quran, in this example the most efficient way to fulfill all the daily Contact Prayers is to do five daily Contact Prayers.
These five daily Contact Prayers don’t have official names, but for easier communication let’s label them here as the night prayer, the dawn prayer, the noon prayer, the afternoon prayer, and the sunset prayer. As you can see from this timetable, there is some wiggle room, a margin of freedom, in when you can do these five prayers, as long as you hit all those same colors with the same arrow. So you can do the night Contact Prayer at any time when there is full darkness in the sky, which is when the sun is more than 18° below the horizon. Then, from the moment the sun reaches 18° below the horizon until sunrise, you can do the dawn prayer. Then, from the moment the sun reaches its maximum elevation until it declines to 45° above the horizon, you can do the noon prayer, and after that, the afternoon prayer, until sunset, after which the sunset prayer can be done until the sun reaches 18° below the horizon. If you want to know why 18°, watch my other Friday sermon, titled “Twilight (Evening Dawn).”
So these are the five Contact Prayers at the equator, which is what happens in Mecca as well, and in most of the world during most of the year. There are rare cases, however, in specific locations and at specific times of the year, where you can fulfill these 19 verses, all these Quranic obligations, with fewer than five prayers, and in those cases you should do so. Again, work smarter, not harder. For example, if the day is very short, let’s say in Sweden in winter, these brownish colors move to the left, and when they move all the way to the left, where these green colors are, they practically come to the same place as the green colors, which means that we can then hit all these browns and greens with one single arrow instead of two. Basically, we would need only one prayer there, and it would count as both the noon and the afternoon prayer at the same time. Or, for example, if the day is so long that night doesn’t happen at all, as in Norway during summer, then these blue colors are completely absent, and in that case we do not need this arrow to hit these blue colors. They don’t exist, and in that case we just don’t do the night Contact Prayer. There’s no night. I’m not stopping you from doing it, but it simply doesn’t exist, and you cannot apply something which doesn’t exist.
Anyway, the point which I’m trying to make is that in general there are five Contact Prayers per day, through which we fulfill these 19 verses. But in rare cases, in rare locations, during a portion of the year, we can fulfill those 19 verses with four prayers, or, in even rarer cases, with three prayers, and in extremely rare cases with two prayers, and in the most extreme cases, at the North and South Poles, with only one prayer. I give all these cases, and the exact circumstances, times and locations where they happen, in the video clarification titled “Times of Contact Prayers.” And on top of that, there are other exceptions, when you’re allowed to pray without doing the actual body movements, which the Quran allows more and more in our busy modern world, and you can learn more about those exact conditions, or exceptions, in my other Friday sermon, titled “Lessening and Shortening the Contact Prayers in Civilized Spaces.”
