[search-in-place-form in_current_page="1"]

People in Position of Weakness Tend to Lie, People in Position of Power Tend to Break Their Promises

Friday Sermon by: Alban Fejza, Online Congregation Director

Summary:

In this Friday sermon, Alban Fejza comments on a news report about Afghanistan to show that people in a position of weakness tend to lie, while people in a position of power tend to break their promises, and explains how being aware of this protects us without making us suspicious of everyone.

Video Transcript:

Today I did not have something very important to share with you, so I thought I could comment shortly on this video, which seems to be a CNN report. The report was published around 2011, and it tries to show that most of the people in Afghanistan have never heard of 9/11. Let’s hear part of it.

[A clip from the report is played: the reporter, on patrol with US Marines in Helmand province, shows two young Afghan men pictures of 9/11 and asks what they know about it. They say they have never heard of it.]

From my life experience, I have realized that most people in a position of weakness will mostly lie if they think they cannot get caught. These guys are in a weak position. They are being asked those questions in the presence of soldiers with guns. What does the journalist expect the answer to be? If they said that they know what those pictures are, what could be the next question? The next question would be: what do you think of that event? Do you think that it is a good thing or a bad thing? If they say a good thing, they are afraid of the soldiers. If they say a bad thing, they know that they are being recorded, and eventually their village will hear what they said in the video. So those two guys will probably choose to lie and say that they don’t know what it is.

Now let me show you a soldier who seems to be convinced that they told the truth.

[A clip is played in which a soldier says he is not surprised by their answers and describes how isolated the local people are.]

This soldier is mostly brainwashed from his experience in the United States. He has probably learned that most people will tell you the truth. Most of the things his parents told him, his teachers told him, his commanders, the colleagues around him, they mostly told him the truth, and he thinks that the same situation will be in Afghanistan as well. He fails to realize that the reason people in the US mostly told him the truth is because most of them did not think he could harm them or benefit them, so they mostly had no reason to lie. But in Afghanistan, they see him as a potential source of benefit or as a potential source of harm, so they are motivated to lie. So clearly the rich people are not aware how much the poor people are ready to lie. On the other hand, the poor people are not aware how much the rich people are willing to fool you with promises. People in a position of power usually lie less, but they almost always break their promises.

Let me show you another part from that same video.

[A clip is played in which an Afghan man complains that the Americans promised to help, but destroyed buildings and never delivered the help.]

So this guy is disappointed that the Americans said that they would help, but they did not help. Well, that’s what most people in power usually do. They give promises and do not keep them.

Now let me show you another part of that same media report, where they conclusively seem to prove their point that people in Afghanistan do not know what 9/11 is. But it is actually a triple lie, or a triple manipulation of truth.

[A clip is played citing a 2010 survey which reported that 92 percent of Afghan men in Helmand and other provinces had no idea what 9/11 was.]

So they are saying that 92 percent of Afghan men do not know what 9/11 was. Well, the first manipulation is that the video creates the illusion that the survey was done with pictures, where people could see the pictures. But in fact they are talking about a completely different survey without pictures, while showing another recording which shows the pictures.

Also, a few of the people in Afghanistan would claim not to know what 9/11 is, because in most countries, especially in Muslim countries, they do not say “9/11.” They either say “September 11th,” or they have their own months; they do not necessarily use the Christian calendar. If you ask them, “Do you remember those buildings which were destroyed in America?” they would probably remember. A lot of them actually think that the Americans destroyed the buildings themselves. So maybe the question should be, “Do you remember those two large buildings which the Americans destroyed and then blamed the Muslims for?” They would probably say yes. So whoever did that survey probably lacked awareness of how locals in that region think. They don’t have “9/11” in their vocabulary; they describe it with completely different words.

The first time I heard the term “9/11” in US media, I also did not know what they were talking about, until I realized that they were talking about the attack which was carried out by al-Qaeda on the 11th of September. You see, I know it as the 11th of September. As a European, in Europe we say the day first and then the month. If they asked me about 9/11, I would need to sort of rewire my brain first before I could answer.

Anyway, the third layer of the lie is the intentional spin of this report, as the media usually do. They probably know that the survey was not perfect, but since this report might support one political party with which they are associated, they publish the video report anyway. This kind of manipulation, by reporting unscientific surveys, is done by all sides of the media.

Anyway, what I’m trying to say is that it would probably save us a lot of energy in our life if we realize that most people in a position of weakness will lie, and most people in a position of power will break their promises when they can get away with it. And the point of what I’m saying is not to encourage us to go around trying to find who is lying and who is breaking promises. That’s not the point. The point is that if you don’t want to get fooled and hurt, don’t rely too much on the information which people weaker than you tell you, and don’t rely too much on the promises which people stronger than you give you.

For example, if you go to a job interview, and the people in that company tell you that the salary in the beginning will be this much, and then after several years they might consider an increase, don’t make your decision based on what they promise you, if you don’t think that the lower salary will benefit you anyway. They might be forced to increase your salary if it is in the contract, but if they can find a way not to keep their promise, they will most likely not keep it. Politicians, for example, almost never keep their promises. They will keep them if it is easy and if they think that it will benefit their future career, but not because they gave a promise.

Anyway, I hope you do not take this video as an excuse to become suspicious of everyone. The point of this video is to increase our awareness of how this world mostly works, but not to make us bitter people, people who are suspicious of everything. This is why the Quran mentions the jinns, who are in a weaker position than humans, as liars, and Satan, who is currently in a stronger position than humans, is described in the Quran as a promise breaker.