What is Ash’arism?

Ash’arism is a theological school of thought within Islamic theology that emerged in the 10th century, founded by the scholar Abu al-Hasan al-Ash’ari (873–935 CE). It became one of the most influential theological schools in Sunni Islam and has had a lasting impact on Islamic thought, especially in the areas of doctrine, philosophy, and theology.

Ash’arism arose as a response to earlier theological debates, particularly in relation to Mu’tazilism, and sought to find a middle ground between rationalism and revelation. The school emphasized the importance of divine revelation (as found in the Quran and Hadith) and the authority of traditional sources, while also incorporating elements of rational thought.

Core Beliefs and Doctrines of Ash’arism

1. God’s Absolute Sovereignty (Tawhid)
   • A central tenet of Ash’arism is the belief in Tawhid, the absolute oneness and unity of God. Ash’arism emphasizes that God is unique, eternal, and incomparable. He is the only necessary being, while everything else is contingent upon His will and power.
   • Ash’arism rejects any anthropomorphic views of God (attributing human-like characteristics to God) and stresses that God is beyond the limits of human comprehension.
2. God’s Power and Will
   • According to Ash’arism, God is the absolute cause of everything that happens in the universe. Causality, from this perspective, is not a natural law but a manifestation of God’s will. Every action or event, no matter how ordinary it seems, is directly caused by God’s will.
   • Ash’arism holds that God’s power is unrestricted and that He can act in ways that may transcend human understanding. Unlike the Mu’tazilites, who believed that natural laws function independently of God’s will, Ash’arism teaches that all natural events are created by God in each moment. This view is often referred to as occasionalism.
3. The Nature of the Quran
   • One of the key theological debates in early Islam was about the nature of the Quran. The Mu’tazilites believed the Quran was created, while Ash’arism, following the mainstream Sunni position, maintained that the Quran is uncreated and eternal.
   • For Ash’arites, the Quran is the eternal word of God, revealed to the Prophet Muhammad, and it remains infallible in its transmission and content.
4. Divine Justice and Human Free Will
   • While Ash’arism emphasizes God’s absolute power, it also holds that God is just and fair. However, the Ash’arites argue that human beings, while having free will, cannot act independently of God’s will. Every action, good or bad, is ultimately decreed by God, yet human beings are still accountable for their choices.
   • This position is a departure from the Mu’tazilite view, which stressed that human beings have complete free will to act independently of God’s predestination. The Ash’ari position maintains that God’s justice is beyond human comprehension, and His will is always aligned with what is ultimately best for creation, even if humans cannot fully understand it.
5. The Role of Reason and Revelation
   • Ash’arism recognizes the importance of both reason and revelation, but it gives precedence to divine revelation over human reason. Ash’arites believe that reason alone cannot lead to an understanding of God’s nature or ultimate truths. Instead, reason must be guided by revelation (the Quran and Hadith).
   • They argue that while reason is important for understanding the natural world and engaging with ethical issues, there are mysteries of faith that are beyond the grasp of human reason and can only be understood through divine revelation.
6. Iman (Faith) and Action
   • Ash’arism asserts that faith (iman) is both belief in the heart and action. A person is considered a true believer if they accept the core tenets of faith (such as belief in the oneness of God, the prophethood of Muhammad, the Quran, and the Day of Judgment), and also live according to the teachings of Islam through righteous actions and worship.
   • Unlike the Mu’tazilites, who emphasized the importance of human effort in achieving salvation, Ash’arism posits that both God’s grace and human effort are necessary for salvation. However, ultimate salvation is determined by God’s mercy, not by human merit alone.
7. Theological Anthology
   • Ash’arism includes a discussion on the attributes of God and how they relate to His essence. Ash’arites maintain that God’s attributes (such as His knowledge, power, and will) are eternal and are not separate from His essence, as opposed to some philosophers who treated divine attributes as distinct from God’s essence.
   • The Ash’ari position maintains that humans should not attempt to fully understand or speculate about God’s attributes beyond what is revealed in the Quran and Hadith, rejecting anthropomorphic interpretations.

The Methodology of Ash’arism

1. Use of Kalam (Islamic Theological Discourse)
   • Kalam, meaning “speech” or “discussion,” refers to the systematic theological debates and discourse in Islam. Ash’arism is a school within Kalam that seeks to engage with issues of faith using dialectical reasoning and rational arguments, while still adhering to the teachings of the Quran and Hadith.
   • The Ash’ari methodology focuses on defending orthodox Sunni beliefs, answering philosophical challenges, and resolving theological issues through rational argumentation grounded in Islamic scripture.
2. The Concept of “Occasionalism”
   • Occasionalism is the belief that cause-and-effect relationships in the world do not operate independently but are directly created by God at every moment. For Ash’arism, God is the only true cause of every event, and natural laws are simply patterns established by God. This view was developed to address challenges to the traditional understanding of causality, particularly from the rationalist school of Mu’tazilism.
   • For example, if a fire burns a piece of wood, the Ash’ari view holds that God directly causes the burning whenever the conditions are met, rather than the fire causing it in an independent manner.
3. Theology of the Afterlife
   • The Ash’ari position on the afterlife aligns with traditional Sunni beliefs in resurrection, judgment, and paradise. They believe in the physical resurrection of the body on the Day of Judgment, and the eternal reward of the righteous in paradise (Jannah) or punishment for the wicked in hell (Jahannam).

Influence of Ash’arism

1. Influence on Sunni Islam
   • Ash’arism became the dominant theological school in Sunni Islam, and its influence remains significant to this day. It shaped the theological positions of many Sunni scholars and schools, particularly in theological curriculum and jurisprudence.
   • Ash’arism’s emphasis on divine revelation and reason guided the orthodox Sunni establishment and helped maintain a balance between Islamic orthodoxy and philosophical engagement.
2. The Ash’ari School and Islamic Law
   • The Ash’ari approach to theology also influenced Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh), as their emphasis on God’s ultimate authority and predestination resonated with legal scholars in their interpretation of divine commands and human responsibility.
3. Criticism and Alternatives
   • Ash’arism faced criticism, particularly from Mu’tazilites, who emphasized human free will and rationalism. In contrast, the Maturidi school, which emerged as a rival Sunni theological school, shares many beliefs with Ash’arism but offers a slightly different approach to the nature of human will and the interpretation of divine attributes.

Conclusion

Ash’arism is a major theological school in Sunni Islam, focusing on the importance of divine revelation, the absolute sovereignty of God, and the compatibility of reason with faith. It emerged as a response to the rationalist Mu’tazilite school, advocating a middle path that emphasizes the transcendence of God while also acknowledging the role of reason in understanding theological concepts. Ash’arism has profoundly shaped Sunni theology, influencing Muslim beliefs about God’s nature, human responsibility, and the afterlife. Its balance between revelation and rational discourse continues to be a defining feature of Sunni Islamic thought.

Written by AI.  A more correct, God given, explanation can be found here.