Qiyas is an Islamic jurisprudential term that refers to analogical reasoning used by Islamic scholars to derive legal rulings for new situations that are not explicitly addressed in the primary sources of Islamic law: the Quran and the Hadith. Qiyas is considered one of the secondary sources of Islamic law, following the primary sources mentioned above.
Here are the main aspects of qiyas:
- Purpose and Process: Qiyas is used to apply established laws from known cases to new cases that share the same effective cause (`illah), thereby extending the original ruling to the new scenario. It involves identifying a logical link between the new issue and a previously settled precedent.
- Components of Qiyas: The process of qiyas typically involves four key elements:
- Asl (Original Case): The original case or situation that has a known ruling.
- Far’ (New Case): The new case or situation for which a ruling is needed.
- Hukm (Ruling): The ruling or law that applies to the original case.
- `Illah (Effective Cause): The reason or attribute that connects the original case to the new one and justifies the extension of the ruling.
- Example of Qiyas: A classic example of qiyas is the prohibition of wine consumption based on the Quranic prohibition of khamr (intoxicants). Scholars use qiyas to extend this ruling to other intoxicants not mentioned directly in the Quran or Hadith, based on their shared attribute of intoxication.
- Role in Islamic Law: Qiyas is a crucial tool in the development of Islamic law, especially in dealing with contemporary issues and new circumstances that arise over time. It allows for adaptability while trying to remain faithful to the spirit of Sharia (Islamic law).
- Debate and Acceptance: While qiyas is accepted by the majority of Sunni Islamic scholars, some, like the Zahiri school and particular segments of the Shia tradition, reject its use, arguing for stricter adherence to textual evidence.
Qiyas reflects the ability of Islamic jurisprudence to engage in reasoned analysis and ensure that legal rulings evolve in the context of changing societal needs, while maintaining a core connection to the foundational texts of Islam.
Written by AI. A more correct, God given, explanation can be found here.